Detached House for sale at 528 First Avenue, Tay, Ontario, L0K 1R0 - Port McNicoll - MLS: S13816372

new
for sale
for lease
sold
leased
terminated
expired
suspended

528 First Avenue

Tay, Ontario, L0K 1R0 - Port McNicoll

$649,999

Neighbourhood

Port McNicoll
Major Intersection

Talbot & First Ave

Listed Since: 1 day(s)
Last update: today

Overview

Property Type

Detached, 1 1/2 Storey
Bedrooms

3
Bathrooms

2
Basement

Unfinished + Crawl Space
Kitchen

1
Total Parking

15 (3 Detached Garage)
Lot Size

80x104 (Feet)
Taxes

$3,216.00 (2026)
Type

Freehold

Property Description

Property description for 528 First Avenue, Tay

A beautifully renovated home, a quiet Georgian Bay setting, and space to enjoy it all! Welcome to 528 First Avenue, where move-in-ready comfort meets the relaxed luxury of life by the water. Beautifully renovated and thoughtfully maintained, this inviting 3-bedroom, 1.5-bath home offers a wonderful opportunity to settle in, slow down and simply enjoy where you live. Inside, you'll find a home that has been cared for with intention, featuring tasteful updates, newer appliances and a warm, welcoming atmosphere that makes it easy to picture yourself here. Nothing to renovate, nothing to tackle - just unpack, settle in and start enjoying.Outside, the lifestyle truly takes over. Set on a generous lot with a vacant lot next door, there's a sense of privacy and breathing room that's increasingly hard to find. Gather around the fire pit beneath the evening sky, enjoy summer afternoons in the yard or take a leisurely stroll to the shores of Georgian Bay. With beautiful walking trails and the water just steps away, nature becomes part of your everyday rhythm.Then there's the 30' x 24' shop - an exceptional bonus for hobbyists, outdoor enthusiasts and anyone who appreciates having room for their toys, projects and passions. Whether it's trail-riding gear, recreational equipment, a workshop or simply enviable storage space, this is the kind of feature that makes everyday living that much more enjoyable.Located in the welcoming community of Port McNicoll, this is a place where neighbours feel familiar, life moves at a gentler pace and weekends are made for getting outside. A beautifully updated home, an incredible amount of usable space and the freedom to embrace a quieter lifestyle - this home is ready for you to simply move in and enjoy!

Listed by CENTURY 21 B.J. ROTH REALTY LTD.

Property details

MLS #

S13816372
Sq. Ft

1100-1500
Sq. Ft. Source

MLS
Lot Irregularities

n/a
Year Built

Available Upon Request
Pool

None
Drive

Private
Garage

Detached, 3 spaces
Total Parking

15
Family Room

N
Den

N
Exterior

Vinyl Siding
Fireplace

N
Roof

Asphalt Shingle
Foundation

Concrete
Elevator

n/a
Water View

n/a
Laundry Level

n/a
Heat

Forced Air
A/C

Central Air
Water

Municipal
Water Supply

n/a
Sewers

Septic
Central Vac

N

MLS #

S13816372
Sq. Ft

1100-1500
Sq. Ft. Source

MLS
Lot Irregularities

n/a
Year Built

Available Upon Request
Pool

None
Drive

Private
Garage

Detached, 3 spaces
Total Parking

15
Family Room

N
Den

N
Exterior

Vinyl Siding
Fireplace

N
Roof

Asphalt Shingle
Foundation

Concrete
Elevator

n/a
Water View

n/a
Laundry Level

n/a
Heat

Forced Air
A/C

Central Air
Water

Municipal
Water Supply

n/a
Sewers

Septic
Central Vac

N

Dining

3.1 x 4.11 ft Main level
Kitchen

4.14 x 3.35 ft Main level
Br

7.7 x 4.22 ft Main level
Bathroom

0.91 x 1.68 ft Main level
Br

3.4 x 4.17 ft 2nd level
2nd Br

3.25 x 3.2 ft 2nd level
3rd Br

2.51 x 4.34 ft 2nd level
Bathroom

1.57 x 2.64 ft 2nd level

Contact Manoj Kukreja

Sales Representative,
Century 21 People’s Choice Realty Inc.,
Brokerage
(647) 576 - 2100

Property History

Property history for 528 First Avenue, Tay

This property has been sold 2 times before. Create your free account to explore sold prices, detailed property history, and more insider data.

Local Real Estate Price Trends for Detached in Port McNicoll

Active listings

Average Selling Price of a Detached

August 2026

$391,500

Last 3 Months

$437,971

Last 12 Months

$439,039

August 2025

$450,000

Last 3 Months LY

$481,444

Last 12 Months LY

$541,115

Change

-13%

Change

-9%

Change

-19%

Historical Average Selling Price of a Detached in Port McNicoll

Average Selling Price

3 years ago

$631,667

Average Selling Price

5 years ago

$468,500

Average Selling Price

10 years ago

$234,000

Change

-38%

Change

-16%

Change

67%

How many days Detached takes to sell (DOM)

August 2026

Last 3 Months

Last 12 Months

August 2025

Last 3 Months LY

Last 12 Months LY

Change

-52%

Change

22%

Change

24%

Average Selling price

Mortgage Calculator

This data is for informational purposes only.

Mortgage Payment per month
Principal Amount	Interest
Total Payable	Amortization

Property Price

Amortization

Rate of Interest

Down Payment ($)

Down Payment (%)

Closing Cost Calculator

This data is for informational purposes only.

Closing Cost Total for this property

Total Cash flow for purchasing this property

Purchase Price

First time home buyer

Down Payment($)

Down Payment(%)*

Additional information

Provincial Land Transfer Tax

Ontario Land Transfer Tax Rebate

Toronto Land Transfer Tax

Toronto Land Transfer Tax Rebate

PST on CMHC Insurance Premium

Lawyer Fees

$2,825

Government Registration Fee's

$164

Title Insurance

Closing Cost Total

Total Cash flow for purchasing this property

Provincial Land Transfer Tax

Ontario Land Transfer Tax Rebate

Toronto Land Transfer Tax

Toronto Land Transfer Tax Rebate

PST on CMHC Insurance Premium

Lawyer Fees

$2,825

Government Registarion Fee's

$164

Title Insurance

Purchase Price

Down Payment($)

Down Payment(%)*

First time home buyer

* A down payment of less than 20% is permitted only for first-time home buyers purchasing their principal residence. The minimum down payment required is 5% for the portion of the purchase price up to $500,000, and 10% for the portion between $500,000 and $1,500,000. For properties priced over $1,500,000, a minimum down payment of 20% is required.

Contact Manoj Kukreja

Sales Representative, Century 21 People’s Choice Realty Inc., Brokerage
(647) 576 - 2100

Similar Properties Recently sold

157 Parkview Avenue

Orillia, Ontario, L3V 4M2 - Orillia

3 Bedrooms
1100-1500 Sq Ft
2 Baths
5 Garage

$659,900

125 Toronto Street

Barrie, Ontario, L4N 1V3 - Queen's Park

3 Bedrooms
1100-1500 Sq Ft
2 Baths
7 Garage

$699,900

52 Seventh Street

Collingwood, Ontario, L9Y 2A7 - Collingwood

3 Bedrooms
1100-1500 Sq Ft
2 Baths
4 Garage

$749,000